Mississippi Mud Pie

A rich and indulgent Mississippi Mud Pie with a chocolate cookie crust, fudgy brownie, silky pudding, and fresh whipped cream. Perfect to make ahead!

The post Mississippi Mud Pie appeared first on Budget Bytes.

This rich, indulgent, showstopping Mississippi Mud Pie recipe is a chocolate lover’s DREAM. It starts with a chocolate cookie crust, which is topped with a fudgy brownie layer, then chocolate pudding, and finished with homemade whipped cream. It’s downright delicious! But I won’t lie, this recipe does take time to make (I like to spread it out over two days to give each layer time to cool). Now, don’t let that scare you! I’ve broken each step down so it’s doable using just budget-friendly ingredients, and I promise you, every layer of this Mississippi mud pie is so worth it.

Side view of a slice of Mississippi Mud Pie.

Four Layer Mississippi Mud Pie

The origins of Mississippi Mud Pie are, fittingly, a little muddy! There are plenty of stories and even more variations, but the version I’m sharing here is the one most people think of when they picture this classic dessert. When my boyfriend first suggested I make this recipe, I had no idea what I was getting myself into. This Mississippi mud pie is essentially four desserts stacked into one! Chocolate sandwich cookies are crushed to make a crust that takes just minutes, then I bake a homemade brownie layer right on top. The third layer is our slightly modified tried-and-true rich silky chocolate pudding recipe, with the final layer being a cloud of homemade whipped cream.

The secret to this recipe for Mississippi mud pie is time and cooling. As I mentioned, I usually make my pie over two days, so I’m not overwhelmed. But after you’ve made it once, it feels like a breeze! My advice? Take your time, and enjoy the process. I know you’ve got this, and trust me, the reward is a delicious pie that tastes like pure chocolate heaven.

I was able to pour my melted butter straight into the ziplock bag I used to crush the cookies in. If you punctured the bag during the crushing process or crushed the cookies in a food processor, pour the cookie crumbs into a bowl, then fold in the melted butter.
Take your time with each layer. I used my hands and a measuring cup to really press the crust together and up the sides of the pie pan. See our peanut butter pie recipe for another example of a pie made with a chocolate sandwich cookie crust.
This Mississippi mud pie recipe will also work with a graham cracker crust (either homemade or store-bought).
The brownie batter will be thick! I used a spoon and my fingers to gently push the batter around the crust.
Be patient when making the chocolate pudding. The cornstarch is what thickens it, and the heat is what activates the cornstarch. Just keep whisking until the pudding is heated through and thick. Take your time.
After the pudding is carefully poured and spread over the cooled brownie layer, make sure to lightly press a sheet of plastic wrap over the pudding so a skin does not form. At this point, I like to refrigerate the whole pie overnight.
I finished my Mississippi mud pie with whipped cream and a layer of chopped chocolate chips. You can also top the cream with chopped nuts, crushed cookies, fresh berries, chocolate syrup, toffee bits, cocoa powder, or sugared cranberries for the holidays!